search web kakiseni
[ go ]

member login

register now | why register?
registration/login problems?



BOH Cameronian Arts Awards

"If you are not criticized, you may not be doing much"

- Donald H. Rumsfeld
You are not logged in.
articles

 View on a single page

07. 04. 2005
Experiment in Bronze by Antares

On opening night of Monkey Business, director Krishen Jit wasn’t sitting like a stone deity in the foyer with an inscrutable look on his face, as is his wont. He was recuperating from another cardiac arrest in the National Heart Institute. However, those involved with Five Arts Centre seemed quite cheerful as they went about their business as usual. Perhaps they know that as long as the show goes on, Krishen will be motivated to get back on his feet. I’m inclined to think the man has the tenacity to soldier on till his hundredth birthday, heart condition be damned. On the other hand, I was acutely aware that this might well be the last time the venerable doyen of alternative Malaysian theatre, whose career spans nearly half a century, would be allowed (by his doctors if not his detractors) to put his unmistakable stamp on a theatrical event.

Knowing this rather sets a constraint on any reviewer who might otherwise be tempted to sink his or her teeth into the production and savage it a little. So I’m not going to carp too much about the few moments that made me want to slap my forehead and groan or quietly leave during the intermission, as a handful of people did.

Instead, I’ll focus on the few truly sublime bits which made me glad I stayed till the very end. I’ve always been fond of Sunetra Fernando and impressed by her work, specifically with Rhythm In Bronze, the gamelan ensemble she leads alongside Jillian Ooi. Fernando and Ooi’s accomplishments, as artistic and music directors of this expressionistic fusion of music, dance and theatre, were genuinely commendable. But several times during the performance I found myself closing my eyes so I could relish the music as pure music. Monkey Business was certainly a quirky experiment in pushing the frontiers of gamelan music – and, thankfully, a highly successful one in that the ‘avant-garde’ use of gamelan instruments proved refreshing and stimulating. RIB really ought to record their performances and release the best takes as a CD or DVD. Their first album, a studio production, was somewhat lacking in the verve, vigour and classy ambience that characterise their live performances. The only way to capture the vibrant excitement of RIB is via a live recording.

It’s been less than a week since I caught Monkey Business and, alas, I’ve already forgotten what most of the segments were all about. I remember thinking the contrived cacophony and chaos of transitions between pieces was a tad too cutesy for my taste and way overdone. Krishen has consistently used variations of this scene-changing device for well over a decade, just as he has inserted the random factor of the lucky draw into the order of sequences in countless productions. True, these dramaturgic strategies still work, to a certain extent, but the ‘cutting edge’ effect has long been blunted.

Two or three pieces, however, were so impeccably executed that the memory of aesthetic pleasure remains vivid. For me, the high point of the entire production was Melvin Ho’s contribution, ‘There Was This Dream’, in which three ‘monks’ on gamelan begin a contemplative piece and are soon set upon by demons and gremlins of distraction and discord. The trio valiantly stick to their meditative course and successfully complete their musical pilgrimage to the transcendent heights of serenity and ethereal beauty. It was reminiscent of that scene in Little Buddha when Prince Siddhartha (played by Keanu Reeves) defeats Mara – archetypal tempter and Demon-King of Samsara – simply by ignoring every malicious attempt to disrupt his concentration.

The only thing that stuck in my mind about Susan Sarah John’s offering, ‘Carbon’, was her uncredited opening quote from Amadeus (the Miloš Forman movie), in which Antonio Salieri attempts to negotiate a deal with God, sacrificing his libido in exchange for musical immortality (“Dear God make me immortal. After I die let people speak my name forever with love for what I wrote. In return I will give You my chastity, my industry, my deepest humility, every hour of my life, Amen”). It was unwittingly appropriate an allusion, since much of the thematic content of Monkey Business seemed to be the product of repressed eroticism – or arrested adolescence masquerading as childlike playfulness. But, then again, that may simply be the way most Malaysians are brought up. What else do you expect, after all, in a culture where men and women are encouraged to stay fully clothed on the beach?

As a performer, Mohd Sobri Anuar Mohd Tarmizi shows great promise and stage presence. I was reminded of Khalid Salleh’s ability to mesmerise, acquired from real life experience as a streetwise medicine seller. Sobri’s energy carried a pronounced shamanic quality, which more than compensated for any lack of technical or linguistic finesse. Unfortunately, his strong personality tended to obscure all other considerations, and I can’t for the life of me remember what he was getting at in each of his solo routines.

Venezuelan dancer-choreographer, Judimar Hernandez de Monfils, was an enchanting powerhouse of mercurial elegance – and always a pleasure to watch, even if her presence occasionally seemed gratuitous and purely ornamental, the way it did in an earlier collaboration with Rhythm In Bronze, in Sutra’s Festival of Contemporary Dance Theatre & Music staged in 2003. To my mind, Ms Monfils is so exquisite a dancer, one simply wants her to fill the entire stage with her lithe and statuesque form – instead of watching her compete with actors and musicians for the audience’s attention.

As a closing piece, Bernard Goh’s ‘Borderless’ was absolutely dynamic and fiercely inspiring. Goh, founder-director of Hands Percussion, led two other members of the team – Chew Soon Heng and Jimmy Ch’ng – in a rousing display of precision drumming and Chinese-style acrobatics. It was a sure-fire way to dispel the stagey neuroticism of some of the preceding works and end the show on a high. The audience left feeling benignly charged up and optimistic about life in general, and dance-music-theatre experiments in particular.

~ ~ ~

Antares is an artist, actor, dancer, musician and writer; he is a living, walking dance-music-theatre experiment.

 View on a single page

User Comments

posted by Nomonkeybusiness
Well said Antares. You are rather diplomatic though. Too kind indeed.
It was EXCRUCIATING!
If this is considered experimental, I will be worry for the state of our performing arts. It is rather an irresponsible piece of performance. Irresponisble to its audience. Lazy in its idea and execution.
I don't understand why our local performers quite often then not, resort to lurid act or attempt to being funny when things don't seem to work on stage. To me, it is a poor attempt in hiding their inadequacy.
There was more than a handful walked out the night I was there. I soldier on for the second half and wished I hadn't.

 

posted by -LJT-
having been to a couple of performance by Rhythm In Bronze, i was all pumped up for this latest edition by the brilliant Sunetra and team..even manage to convince a couple of my mates to experienced it for the 1st time..in general the crowd gave half hearted applause and in certain pieces we weren't sure if it had ended or not..many of us were expecting to be entertained by something light hearted and relaxing on a sunday afternoon..IMHO, a tad too serious..miss the joyful expression of the team that we are accustomed to..the show did end with a big bang but by that time the crowd were counting the number of pieces left..great attempt by the whole team..keep it up!

 

posted by monkeyseemonkeydo
I quote Schopenhauer....Would a musician feel flattered by the loud applause of his audience if it were known to him that, with the exception of one or two, it consisted entirely of deaf people?

hheehehehhhh....
its great to hear views of all of you out there. i love kakiseni.
For monkey biz i personally believe RiB decided to follow internal consciences rather than signs of approval or condemnation from outside.
I think we all (should) agree that what matters is not what we seem to a random group, but what we know we are.

 

posted by monkeyseemonkeydo
I quote Schopenhauer....Would a musician feel flattered by the loud applause of his audience if it were known to him that, with the exception of one or two, it consisted entirely of deaf people?

hheehehehhhh....
its great to hear views of all of you out there. i love kakiseni.
For monkey biz i personally believe RiB decided to follow internal consciences rather than signs of approval or condemnation from outside.
I think we all (should) agree that what matters is not what we seem to a random group, but what we know we are.

 

posted by Lola
personally, I liked it.
Lots

 

posted by Poh Lin
Caught up with a friend during intermission and she asked, "You understand, ah?" I answered,"No, but I like it. Like my dreams lah. Sometimes I don't understand them, but I like them anyway!"

I feel Monkey Business is just a first step in a journey. Sunetra, Bernard and teams are moving on, growing up, synthesizing.

Bon voyage, I say!

 

posted by gamelanfan
Being a big fan of RiB, I must say... the recent show is quite a disappointment. My friend and I (a French) have been looking forward to their next show so badly. Yet, after we went for it...

The show has changed my concept of traditional gamelan.... didn't realise it can be played in so many ways! However, we must admit there's a limit for everything.

Guys, I appreciate your hardwork in trying to 'ubah' our 'fikiran' but sometimes it's better to follow the old rules... don't you think so?

 

posted by Ann
It was definitely not a 'brain-washing' performance. I'd say its alright for us performers, musicians, artist and theater pactitioners not to spoon feed many 'comfortable' audience. Hei guys, its performing arts... Did anyone say there's right or wrong in it? Not that i know of... Some liked it, some had no idea what it was all about...some seriously HATED it.....i must say i had loads of fun being in it. Cheerio!

 

Related Links

    print | e-mail to a friend | post comment