












06. 10. 2004
Enema of the Suburbs by Vanessa Surian
The night finally kicked off after accounting for Malaysian and musicians’ timing. Call the Paramedics opened with catchy funkpop tunes overlaid by a stilted and awkward charm that was quite endearing. Telebury brought things down a little, with 3 guitarists (a slightly under-utilised dynamic though) filling the room with a spacey introspective laziness that I probably just didn’t get the full effect of due to the limits of the sound system. The overall result was reminiscent of Coldplay though lacking in emotional soars. Or the ability to make a word like yellow sound deep.
Soft Touch came with their usual brand of hold-hands-around-the-campfire-and- make-the-world-a-better-place and brought up the energy level tenfold (a slight exaggeration, we’re still Malaysians), a feat achieved half by the music and half by the way Peter Hassan Brown was swinging his hair around.
And then there was Groovetank. I've seen this band once before and came away only with a covetous impulse toward guitarist Zach’s tone and not much else. After this time I might safely be called a fan somewhat. Maybe it was their opening track that did it (with a guest rapper in tow). It reminded me of something you might have found on an album by The Roots (before Phrenology). Or maybe it was that the lead singer and guitarist’s guitarwork reminded me of Geoff Farina (not the toys‘r’us giraffe but the guitarist of Karate). Whatever it was, I would definitely like to see more of them.
Next up was Zhen from Singapore who were brought up here by FYI Entertainment. They came bearing good equipment, a professional air about them (I will not make fun of Singaporeans. I will not make fun of Singaporeans. I will not...), and a female bassist who quite upstaged the guitarist because she was funkay. What? you say. A Prog Rock band where the guitarist is not supreme wanker? Yes, say I. Interesting licks will always prevail over technically stupefying technique. Something all shredheads should know.
For all their prog rockness, they also managed to throw in a rap rock tune, and covers of crowd pleasers. The latter of which brings up my sole complaint. I understand the need to bring the audience in a little and give them something to babble along to, but I maintain that no band should cover Pearl Jam or try to imitate Chris Cornell’s manly screech for the same reason Simon Cowell recommends never singing a Whitney Houston song. You come out second best. Or worse, you might insult the diehard fans. In fact I see no point to covers unless you try to bring something of your bands style into it. But that’s just me, because the audience seemed pleased.
Anyway, the next day. It was the punk rock installment, Hello There Mr Punk!!! I arrived late to arrive on time but was still two hours too soon. Punk rock on a yawny Saturday afternoon? Sometimes I think punk rock and tropical weather don’t mix. Finally, The Blumps opened with a bunch of catchy tunes. Guitarist/lead vocalist Ahmad attempted to relate to the audience by lamenting on the traffic jam and girls who only want you for your Mercedes. Yeah! Whats up with that shit?
I have to confess, I went into a bit of a stupor after this, and one band’s standout factor was them introducing a song “tentang manusia berak” while another band brought me out the stupor shortly with a gleeful punk version of ‘Jingling Nona’ (a paradox that: I've never known a Nona who would jingle even if asked nicely). (It’s actually ‘Jingli Nona’, which according to Google’s translation, means ‘Jingli Ninth’. Huh. – ed.)
I woke up again as Zhen prepared to take the stage. They played a different cover this time, choosing the Goo Goo Doll’s ‘Big Machine’ (a better choice; less sacred, somehow) but the set list was mostly the same as the night before. They had a more relaxed air about them this time and weren’t as tight as the night before. But by then I felt like my jaw was made out of rubber so I can’t blame them. Though not at all punk rock, the best band so far.
The punk picked up though with Smurf from Melaka. I have a snotty question. How do you be punk in Melaka? They managed it, however, with some very tight and fast paced instrumentals. The day had turned into night and the closing band was One Buck Shot (though the lead singer pronounces it as One Buck Short). Ended everything nicely – had the most energy, had synchronised jumping, and a drummer who took off his shirt. A good band, one of the few who didn’t seem to have Blink 182 standing over them and inflicting whiny nasal vocals and their practically signature crunchy arpeggios. The night was over and I failed to take photos of the all the Converse shoes. Dammit.
One of my biggest gripes about the local scene in general is that most bands don’t seem to realise the need to draw from more than one influence. The reason? The same Simon Cowell quote again. Oh yes, and they all need better hair. But there were bands that were exceptions. Groovetank, Zhen, and to some extent One Buck Shot (or Short). Not about the hair though.
I think the fact that Paul’s Place was almost filled to capacity a majority of the time at these two gigs is portentous. In fact it downright bodes. In the shape of a hexagon.
“We crush your lame spirit,
We love your apathy
Love-er-ly…”
– Skunk Anansie, ‘We Love Your Apathy’
Photos by Vanessa Surian
User Comments
| posted by random critic |
| how does the staff of kakiseni choose which underground gigs to review? this was hardly the most provoking or inspiring of the lot... you could have reviewed the reunion of late 80s/early 90s bands that happened at stadium chin woo for its significance. or when the observatory, a singaporean indie band that plays sold-out shows at the esplanade, came to pauls place...
|
| posted by Hassan Peter Brown |
| Hi Pang (I'm addressing you sir because you are the darn editor of this website). Next time why don't you send someone who really knows how to appreciate Malaysian alternative music. It was a shame this review because the writer had practically nothing nice to say about anyone except One Buck Short (yes it's when you go to buy something costing RM20 and you only have RM19 then you are ONE BUCK SHORT - get it?). So you think we are all just imitating Blink 182 - you ought to open your ears my dear Vanessa and actually LISTEN. As for our band (Soft Touch) you probably only listened to "Better World" and then went to the mamak stall for some roti - Camp Fire songs my A**e! And what's so sacred about Pearl (expletive deleted) Jam. Even Zahid from Disagree sings better than Eddy Vedder. Lets give encouragement and appreciation to Malaysian alternative bands who do music for love and make no money and slave in other jobs, let's have writers who are more interested in the music than the artistes' hair or how he shakes it about
|
| posted by Sam |
| Enema of the Suburbs! Haw! Haw! Haw! Very apt indeed! Blink 183? Punk? Haw! Haw! Haw! If Blink is a punk band than Peter Hassan must be KL's Johnny Rotten! Haw! Haw! Haw! And you mean there are kids who wanna be Blink 182? Haw! Haw! Like WHY? And what's so sacred about Pearl Jam anyway? They are the worst "grunge" abortion ever! It's just crap "hair-metal" and "poodle-rock" with bits of Nirvana tacked on! Talk about clueless bands playing a clueless gig, organised by a clueless bunch, reviewed by a clueless writer! Enema indeed! Underground? Haw! Haw! Haw! Haw!
|
| posted by walking zombie |
| just because they're there doing it doesn't make it a compulsory to support them, if the music is just a remake of a remake of a remake, an immitation of an immitation of an immitation, a copy of a copy of a copy, they do not deserve support. what we need are not just people who make music just for the sake of making it, just for the sake of performing gigs, for the sake of sucking up to the audience, for the sake of SUPPORT. No. what we need are people who make real music, original, truly powerful music that truly says something. so what if disagree have the ability to sound better than who who who, so what? just about 3 months ago they were in Hitz fm's countdown, and how did they sounded like on radio?? like JUST ANOTHER BAND (no that's not a band name), nothing great, nothing solid. that's why the process is called a sell-out. and that's more or less what does the local english music scene look like now: a entire line-up of JUST-ANOTHER-BANDs trying cut a crowd, radio-airplay, SUPPORT. all guitar riffs and rapping voices, no real thought. by the way sam, blink 182 IS a punk band, they're just mainstream american pop. and also from your comment you obviously know squat about grunge. Haw Haw. if can't stand the bitching, DO BETTER, it's really that simple. and just because the reviewer didn't write what you want to read, does not mean she's not good enough. we have crap movies reviewed by crap reviewers any day of the week, what the hell are you complaining about? grow up. it's a review, not a a**-licking letter to the boss.
|
| posted by Hassan |
| I think I was a bit grumpy when I wrote that piece (below or above wherever). Apologies to Vanessa and Pang, I've been having sleepless nights! (mainly because I have a high fever - serves me right)
|
| posted by jamal pak tongko |
| hey Vanessa Surian, next time plz make sure that u do some research over anything which u r really interested in doing ur stupid reviews...u r extremely idiot & there's no part of ur review could be considered as good...i wonder why does an idiot & stupid person like u ever exist here in malaysia?...get a life, idiot!...
|
| posted by happytreefriend |
| Things seem pretty heated up in here. My two cents worth, lets not overlook some of the points she did mention. As an avid music fan i too like anyone else on the street would be able to give comments like the ones she made. Most of the time we expect to hear the things we wish to hear. How much effort we put in must be glorified in one way or another. Ever wondered, maybe its because of this back patting culture we have instilled in our local industry which is the reason why were stagnant? Lets not get too engrossed in this culture and make way for those who truly are talented in their fields. Competitiveness is always the key to development in most fields. Be it writing, performing, stageplay, business, and to some sick extent religion. I think the best source of encouragement comes from within ourselves. Desire to be better tommorow than you are today. Dont get me wrong, its not that i turn a deaf ear on comments. Rather than being content with the state were in now, a "bad" review may give us the oppurtunity to turn tables around and start thinking of whats missing with our music. For someone to come up with such "discouraging" remarks, its got to mean something. Being an avid music fan is all the qualification one needs to make such comments. After all they are the poeple who'd buy our music in the end. Lets not make this a personal thing. I stand corrected guys. =)
|
| posted by raoul |
| For the curious, y'all should check out the upcoming Sapu-Sapu series: Sapu-Sapu 3000 on 27th November and Sapu-Sapu 5 (Tiada nomber Empat) on 11th December, both at Paul's Place. This series highlights a lotta bands and performers that tend to get neglected out of the 'cool' clique-y sphere of the 'underground' sphere...apparently. The earlier two series (in January and March earlier this year) had an interesting mix of bands and performers. To beh onest, no one article or review can do justice to encapsulate the 'underground'/'independent' so-called scene (in fact both tags have been used as a marketing tag nowadays). Anyways, that's my two-cents. Do check it out with an open mind.
|
Related Links
print | e-mail to a friend | post comment




