search web kakiseni
[ go ]

member login

register now | why register?
registration/login problems?



BOH Cameronian Arts Awards

"An artist must be a reactionary. He has to stand out against the tenor of the age and not go flopping along."

- Evelyn Waugh
You are not logged in.
articles

 View on a single page

25. 06. 2004
National Unity Crash Course by Zedeck Siew

My time at National Service began on 24th March and ended 4th of June. I was part of Series 2. I spent the first month at a camp in Kuala Kubu Bahru and the rest at Kolej 14, UPM. We were occasionally forced to watch movies, to keep us out of our rooms and out of trouble during the evening hours. The movies we were made to watch throughout, in chronological order:

1. Leftenan Adnan
2. MX3
3. Keluarga 69
4. Leftenan Adnan
5. MX3
6. The Last Samurai
7. Buli
8. The Italian Job (the F. Gary Gray remake)

Also four episodes of TV1 serial Insurgensi, a half-fictionalised dramatisation of Parti Komunis Malaysia’s uprising during the 70s. The production house logo facsimiles Lucasfilm’s exactly (animation, lens-flare, and all). A Leftenan Kolonel wrote the script. The actors, of course, were not playing humans.

They showed us Leftenan Adnan for obvious reasons; MX3 and Buli are Paragons of Malay-language Komedi, Keluarga 69 was made by a National Treasure, The Last Samurai illustrates our Pandang ke Timur policy, and The Italian Job is, well – it has to be taken in context.

It was screened to us in a darkened hall, with an LCD projector and a laptop. It had a ticker running: “For Promotional Purposes Only”, at the bottom. Not all of us were there. Some were up in their rooms, smoking and feigning illness. About forty were at various volleyball courts, practicing for Malam Kebudayaan.

The Malam Kebudayaan was to be our crowning graduation of the Cultural Module, among the four we were supposed to complete, apart from Nationalism (‘Hamba menjunjung duli; Raja adil raja disembah’), Character Building (how to petition parents for money to buy guitar strings) and Community Service (field trips to Sony Bangi and KLIA). These were to help us develop a sense of patriotism as well as unity among the races. As time went by, however, word of the Cultural Module diminished and anticipation of our Malam Kebudayaan increased. The components of Culture they mentioned:

1. dikir barat (Malay)
2. kompang (Malay)
3. tarian India klasik (Indian)
4. tarian Cina klasik (Chinese)

We did the first two. The first night they squatted three hundred of us in a car-park. The facilitators held up the four instruments and shouted their names at us with a loudhailer. The instruments were too soft to hear from where I sat, close to the front. We never got to touch them.

The two dances were shelved due to time / resource constraints, and replaced with a katana-wielding Tom Cruise.

This lack of education did not impair us, culturally. We were not ignorant or apathetic. A tall Sikh fellow told me this socio-politically-conscious joke:

Three young men (Malay / Chinese / Indian) died in a road accident. The Chinese man woke up on the post-mortem table. ‘God told us,’ he said to the surprised doctor, ‘you are too young to die. Pay me RM500 each and I will return you your lives.’

‘What about the other two?’ the doctor asked.

‘The Indian is still bargaining and the Malay is waiting for the government to pay.’

I was thirteen when I first heard the joke. I had agreed with the sentiment then. Now, I told my Sikh friend to shut up.

We were at Pusat Latihan Perindustrian & Pemulihan Bangi (known previously as Pusat Orang Kurang Upaya Bangi), in a conference room. We were waiting for the Muslim boys to finish the afternoon prayers; I opened my notebook. To pass the time I decided to catalogue the Mat Rempit, one of the wondrous and multifarious aspects of Malaysia I had encountered. Call him Awe:

Awe (pronounced a-weh) is a Malay youth, of working class origin (‘Lowest of the Low Class Malay,’ as a middle-class Malay friend of mine put it). He dresses in t-shirt, riding vest, and a pair of jeans worn as high up the waist as possible. He wears a baseball cap with the visor turned up at 45 degrees. Because of his jeans and extended time riding a bike, he has a bow-legged, shuffling gait.

His pride and joy is a motorcycle of reasonable purchase price, but heavily modified, as exemplified by these triumphant lyrics, in which Awe leads us:

Beribu habis duitku
Membuat motorku laju
Malam minggu, ku tertunggu-tunggu
Siapa nak challen aku!

When he first warbled onstage, one night, sounding quite horrific, I was endeared, even more so when the hall sang along. Here was a cute little ditty that, although against Policy (Rempits eventually make your speeding death statistics), authority let be.

Awe is loud, rude, and does not respect personal property. But Rempits in general are considered fashionable enough to garner adequate female attention; this, coupled with the fact they represent a majority at camp, earns contempt of other sects: the Middle Class, the Ah-Bengs, the Tamil Boys, the Sabaks, the Sarawaks, the Anok-anok Kelate and Ganus. (Unfortunately, my experience of NS is male, due to official segregation and an unofficial, zeitgeist-induced discouragement of inter-gender interaction beyond courting.)

You could point out and mark these groups, sitting or standing in clusters during the Malam Kebudayaan. It was held at the Astaka Seni, a building that also houses the local Rakan Muda office. We sat strewn across one of UPM’s thoroughfares. Barricades kept us in. They had to produce a multiracial itinerary, so the show included:

1. tarian Sumazau
2. tarian ala Bollywood
3. tarian kipas Cina
4. dikir barat
5. tarian-tarian Melayu tradisional (Boria, etc.)
6. a band playing ‘Anak Malaysia’
7. joget 70an
8. the Mat Rempit song

To which Awe’s friends got up and jigged. People seated in my immediate vicinity slapped their heads and angry facilitators advanced with loudhailers.

And then a sketch. Brief synopsis:

Warung Pak Mat, Gerai Muthu, and Gerai Ah Chong are food vendors in close proximity. Due to a minor misunderstanding, Pak Mat and Muthu’s youthful patrons ally against Ah Chong’s Chinese thugs. The crisis escalates, tables are folded, fists are traded – when, all of a sudden, a platoon of National Service trainees, in boots and bright blue fatigues, march in stage right and reconcile the fighters, to the programme’s theme song, an upbeat, catchy:

Kami anak-anak Malaysia
Berbagai bangsa, berbagai budaya
Kami sehati sejiwa
Berganding tangan demi Negara

Followed by a deklamasi sajak: ‘Wahai Anakku / Ingatlah Peristiwa Hitam 1969!’

I watched Indian boys group at the curb, animated in conversation and ignoring the stage. Chinese faces occupied the periphery, close to the barricades, waiting to be sent back to our blocks.

I remain unsure of what is Budaya Malaysia according to NS, a programme designed to shape Malaysian youth. This is my guess: Budaya Malaysia consists of Ministry of Culture, Arts and Heritage-sanctioned items – dikir barat, kompang, tarian India klasik, etc.

Of course, recognising Culture wasn’t the priority. The priority was Nationalism, or rather, Defence of the Nation, the purity of its values and traditions, against the (Western) Foreigner. Specifically, according to my Nationalism tutorials, we have to defend ourselves against the United States and Zionists, and by extension, equal rights, freedom of expression, earrings on boys, and other Alien Bogeys.

To facilitate this, the state requires four categories: Malay / Chinese / Indian / Lain-lain. That is also Budaya Malaysia.

The unofficial Malaysia has more extensive ‘cultural’ sub-division: Rempit, Skema, Ah-beng, Ganu. The sentiments mimic those that have been born out of National Policy: these groups have congealed and walled themselves against each other, like racial identities. One girl told me, after I asked whether she could speak Tamil: ‘Can speak, but write I’m not good.’ She then lowered her head conspiratorially. ‘But that Kala – she is like not really Indian. Always speaking Malay, most of her friends are Malay – she speaks Tamil only a little.’

Going through my notebook on the last night of NS, I realised I myself had set Awe in stone; I had drawn up a set of rules and moulded Malay boys in his likeness, even if they did not really wear their jeans above the navel. I was making Identities. Among six hundred youths at the camp who were taught to think the same, I conveniently collapsed them all into a thirteen-year-old. I still agreed, more or less, with my Sikh friend.

This horrified me.

And the ‘country’s future leaders’ still have these attitudes, even after Malam Kebudayaan. National Service desires national unity: it envisions Utopia with racially-specific quarters. It is a miracle cure that cannot work. It is not unlike a religious retreat: at the end everyone is pious, pledging themselves to a renewed devotion to their Deity. It is two weeks before they begin masturbating again.

At Kuala Kubu Bahru, I had the opportunity to speak to my camp director, an amicable Chinese man with a moustache. I asked him whether he thought NS would achieve what it was meant to do.

‘Well, I think it benefits a lot of people,’ he said. ‘You don’t have to look at the big picture. This does not concern you. Just look at yourself, and what you can do in this. I had to pay for Outbound School in my time.’ He explained that he works in finance. Being a volunteer here, he was missing out on the action, as the market was presently going up. ‘So I’m losing a lot of money,’ he added, and began to laugh.

On one of the last nights, I sat with a boy from PJ and a boy from Ranau, on the road below our kolej block, staring at full moon and smoking cigarettes (illegal at camp, 18-above notwithstanding). I was melancholy because three months had made me despair of my country. A group of Rempits were coming up the incline, sweaty from a midnight session of sepak takraw. One, I saw, was wearing Bob Marley wreathed in marijuana.

The Rempits commandeer my friends’ cigarettes, and it is time to leave. My PJ friend says: ‘Beautiful night, but ruined by Rempits.’

 View on a single page

User Comments

posted by JM
Dotty Parker said: You can lead a horticulture but you can't make her think.

Dear Pedant! The tongue-in-cheek pedantry would have been wittier if 'wreath' isn't also a verb. I think Zedeck's use of the word (wreathed in light irony) is perfectly correct and evocative. (Now post something to say that 'perfectly correct' is redundant, go ahead).
In fact the rueful humour of his piece makes this one of Kakiseni's more interesting pieces. But it is the insight into the banality of NS that makes this piece the stuff of a national tragi-comedy.

Perhaps it's because of their own personal conducts, but our macho ministers refuse to accept that "budaya'" is quite simply how we live our quotidian lives and not what we're made to dance or recite The notion that we celebrate our diversity by donning costumes and doing little jigs that nobody does in real life is, of course, absurd. So is forcing young men and women to attend a camp in order to be reminded of our politicized racial heirarchy . Especially since a compulsory viewing of RTM Satu for a week would achieve the same results- docility, alienation, despair etc - without the physical discomfort.

It is simply too daunting for our leaders to nurture a multi-racial popular culture, to revamp national schools from kindergarten onwards, to convince parents that the passing on tired, ingrained prejudices isn't self-defence but self-defeating. Too susah and too long-term. So we have NS.

But how to argue with the NS though? If 'budaya' IS the way we conduct our lives then it is useful for our youth to see that our way is Ito create a Grand Gesture, to inconvenience the helpless and make lots of money from tenders and contracts. In this sense NS is an authentic rite of passage into the adult realities of our system. This, boys and girls, is life.

I congratulate Z for surviving this ridiculous experiment. And am also pleased to note that he has graduated from being statutory rape-bait. Hey buddy, let's meet up and talk about unity and such....

 

posted by JM
Just re-read Pedant's post. I know we're all being cheeky here, but I was wrong in the above post. He/she was indeed correct about 'laurel' and 'marijuana' (Somehow I thought that Pedant's contention was between 'wreath' and 'marijuana'). Oops. I stand contrite - who's the pedant now, eh? Sorry pal!
Offering a long spliff of the finest laurel as apology!

 

posted by golden_showers
thank god we have young breeds like dear zedeck to remind us that towering above proper use of language stand the giants of honest, down to earth, and poetic storytelling. (cheers!) "everything i wanted to know about what zedeck did in NS" woo-hoo! but alas! no scandal-lah! what's wrong people? (not to say that zedeck is not a scandal himself) but malaysia CAN be juicier! ha ha

and why do you always reply to my posts JM? want to tumpang glamour, izzit? ha ha

 

posted by pang
Dear JM

Pedant has a point indeed. He was referring to the original sentence, which read: "wreathed in a laurel of marijuana."

I have since corrected it to "wreathed in marijuana."

Sorry for bad weed.

Speaking of which, here's some relevant socil-political comment from the Tambourine Man himself:

Well, they'll stone ya when you're trying to be so good,
They'll stone ya just a-like they said they would.
They'll stone ya when you're tryin' to go home.
Then they'll stone ya when you're there all alone.
But I would not feel so all alone,
Everybody must get stoned.

 

posted by Rajiv Finn
Dear Zedeck,

It's great to know you've returned in one piece. They really tortured you there huh? But I expected nothing less of such behaviour of a dude of your caliber. Back in high school you were the logical rebel you are now. The world could use more people like you.

Great stuff, hope to see more coming. All the best,

Rajiv Finn

(yeah the guy from high school! loL)

 

posted by feed us
Yeah, many cheers Zedeck & Kakiseni, for this much needed inside view. It's inspiring to know of enlightened youths like Zedeck. More NS rigmaroles, please, and leave us to enjoy the mental & emotional torment of ever more "National" culture, "National" mentality and "National" morality. Such they will have us ingest and regurgitate till it leaves us fairly stoned or simply stonewalled. First "Malaysia Boleh", then this. Next? Ah, the anticipation is enough to turn us Laurus nobilis. Isay, we need more "National" stuffing like we need Cannabis sativa.

Howsoever, with the likes of Zedeck around, there's hope yet that less damage can be done than so portended.

Yeah, yeah, we need more insights like this.

 

posted by farhana
Intersting article. However, me being an NS trainee myself(Pinggiran Pelangi,Bandar Muadzam Shah and UM),I find Zedeck's views, rather pessimistic and judgemental.
First of all, no one should categorise Malays, or anyone for that matter. Calling them 'lowest of the low class malays' doesn't help either.
They are PEOPLE just like you and frankly I don't blame them for being who they are. They live in FELDA and their ONLY entertainment is fagging and 'lumba haram' whereas you, Zedeck can lavishly sunbathe in the presence of cinema's, bowling alleys and shopping malls.
What I found out in NS is that these 'Rempits' are more kind-hearted than any KL-ite I've ever met.So don't only judge from the outside(i.e. what they wear, what they look like).

 

posted by dalcon
Farhana, in all sincerity, would love to hear your story instead. Malaysia needs more discussion like this. If we can't get it on the mainstream press, let's use forums as an alternative.

 

posted by zedeck
farhana, i appreciate your response; i'm not sure whether you've read me precisely, though.

 

posted by Izzany
I am sure there are others who enjoyed the NS? Your views on the Rempit is very classic a veru typical Malaysian Mind. 'Judge the book by its cover' No amount of traning can change a persons background. The goverment should find a new plan.

 

posted by Danny Lim
Farhana seems to have missed the point.

She says Zedeck's views are "pessimistic and judgemental" and that "no one should categorise Malays, or anyone for that matter."

Which all fine and dandy except she then proceeds to be as callously judgemental as her accusations :

"They live in FELDA and their ONLY entertainment is fagging and 'lumba haram' whereas you, Zedeck can lavishly sunbathe in the presence of cinema's, bowling alleys and shopping malls."

In one fell swoop she both judged and categorised the rempits and Zedeck.

Who knows if Zedeck doesn't live in Felda, smoke ciggies and participates in illegal races? Farhana is as guilty for rashly creating identities as Zedeck admits so in the article.

And if she had read properly, it wasn't him that dubbed the rempits 'lowest of the low class malays'.

The folly of NS and indeed, all Malaysians is the way we create Identities, pigeonholing class and ethnicities into digestible caricatures, reducing a complex problem of true cultural integration and ethnic unity into a 3-month outward bound camp teaching dikir barat, tarian kipas and tarian bollywood.

 

posted by Fooji
conclusion: Najib and gang is wasting big money.... as usual.

consolation: There are many Zedecks out there. Malaysia ain;t that bad.

Despair of your country? Well, let's just say you have seen the worst,...it's much beautiful out there, now that you are out, isn't it, Zedeck?

Enjoy your writing for a long time.

 

posted by Sharaad
Why is it that someone like Zadeck can gain so much in critical self-awareness from an experience clearly designed to numb the mind. Or if not designed to numb the mind, which is a tad conspiratorial, then designed by individuals whose minds are so numb (from a self imposed diet of state-sponsored propaganda, or insufficiently nourished by educational philosophy)that they cannot conceive of a pedagogical process that isnt so utterly ineffectual and laughable.

And what of the other participants - hardly models of Hitler's Youth or Singapore's more thorough-going National Service. I wonder what the indifference Zadeck gleams from their faces signifies.

Zadeck's evocation of the Mat Rempit is so wonderful, it makes me want to know what "their" views on this "crash course on national unity" is all about. How they feel about 'national unity'. Bet its more interesting that any number of BN politicians.

I hope only that Zadeck has a fon number and keeps in touch with some of these bow-legged wonderboys of the byways of the Malaysian imaginary.

Perhaps what Zadeck has, which any number of young people might (with his exposure and cultural resources) is an openess to the world, a willingness to suspend judgement, to step back from the impulse to stereotype.

Its people like Zadeck who probably get the most out of life - the banalities of state-sponsored 'education' or the equally sanitised, commodified visions of corporate Global Inc. not withstanding.

Chances is, he'll get the "bigger picture" perhaps because, paradoxically, he's interested the textures and contradictions of the little pixels that make up the whole.

The brilliant mr Zadeck. Lets have more.

 

posted by sharaad kuttan
Apologies, I spelt Zedeck's name incorrectly.

More importantly I wrote:

"Perhaps what Zadeck has, which any number of young people might (with his exposure and cultural resources) is an openess to the world, a willingness to suspend judgement, to step back from the impulse to stereotype."

when I meant to say and thus avoiding the class-based bias:

"Perhaps what Zadeck has, which any number of young people might (EVEN withOUT his exposure and cultural resources) is an openess to the world, a willingness to suspend judgement, to step back from the impulse to stereotype."

 

posted by sharaad
i need an editor, clearly ... enuff said.

 

posted by nilai-nilai
And I did bump into a bunch of NS trainees being herded like cattle by a team leader. Yes, they were being rushed through the exhibits after a perfunctory description of the exhibits that did not take in less than 1 percent of the substance of the exhibits on show. I am lucky to be close to thirty, I guess, because I got to spend more than an hour watching audiovisuals about various winners / fertile scientific "millieus".

I digress. What this herding around smacks of, is low expectations. Schoolteachers and NS trainers, they all seem to have low expectations of young folk. You are not expected to be able to recognise Shakespeare on sight, you don't really need to know what Einstein did nor do you need to be aware of the causes of the Second World War.

Low expectations translate into low performance. It's that simple. for instance, not many young people would have been exposed to community theatre or creative writing; certainly not if left entirely to the devices of government agencies. That means you have to be of a certain class or geographical location in order to stand a better than even chance of "seeing the world" and learning all about it. Which is wrong.

The Anok Kelate and Ganu have every right to be exposed and stimulated. There is every reason to expect much of them. It is a shame if we fail to at least make all Malaysians aware about the opportunities that this world has to offer. It is a failure if we end up as a country of mostly frogs under the coconut shell.

 

Related Links

    print | e-mail to a friend | post comment